Jahangir Siddiqui Capital Markets says OGDC shares which dominate KSE are overvalued by 35% they recommend sell. This points to technical corrections in KSE in few days.
http://www.nation.com.pk/daily/mar-2005/16/bnews5.phpOGDCL behaviour at KSE irrational
KARACHI-The Research Department of Jahangir Siddiqui Capital Markets Ltd. stated that once a while there comes a time when we see certain stocks start behaving in completely irrational manner.
We have started observing such behaviour in OGDCL whose share price has increased by nearly 136% since start of 2005. Keeping in view its dominant position in the benchmark KSE-100 Index, this increase in OGDCL’s share price has contributed nearly 2700 points (68%) of the 3780 points rise in KSE-100 Index. This means that the current privatization news driven rally is more of OGDCL driven rally.
The phenomenal rally in OGDCL stock started with rumors of positive earning surprise in 1HFY05 results.
Market was generally expecting Rs4 plus earnings for 1HFY05 due to positive one time tax adjustment. However, the actual results did not conform to such expectations. Another reason was rumors of privatization related announcement which looks unlikely in the short terms as
Privatisation Commission has too much on its plate at the moment. Keeping in view OGDCL’s huge size (market capitalization of $12.7bn) we expect OGDCL privatization to take a lot of time and PC would prefer to complete PTCL, NLR and PPL transactions before privatizing OGDCL.
They believe the main reason for abnormal increase in OGDCL share price is its dominant position in the market with limited free float. Despite recent increase in its share price some fund managers are likely to stick to their OGDCL holding to make an Index aligned portfolio. With only 5% (215mn shares) of OGDCL shares listed on the market, and 34% weight in benchmark KSE-100 Index, it is simply case of too many hands chasing too few stocks .Due to its limited free float, we believe OGDCL share may have been cornered by some speculators to manipulate the Index direction.
Despite its huge size and being the largest domestic enterprise in terms of profitability OGDCL can sustain a reasonable growth in the long term due to rising oil and gas production, strong oil price outlook and Rupee
devaluation. We expect OGDCL to post a net profit ofRs34.8bn (EPS Rs8.1) during FY05 with cash dividend of Rs6/share. It is currently trading at leading PE of 21.8x with dividend yield of 3.4%. We expect OGDCL profitability to increase at CAGR of 9% during FY05-FY10.
Our fair value for OGDCL stock based on Saudi/Arab Light oil price assumption of US $38.5/barrel during FY05, followed by US $35/barrel in FY06 and $ 32/barrel henceforward is Rs115/share. Saudi/Arab Light trades at $ 8/barrel discount to US oil prices. Assuming prices to remain at current level of $42/barrel, our fair value for OGDCL comes to Rs130. Thus, even in most optimistic case, the current market price is at 35% premium to its fair value. We recommend ‘Sell’ for OGDCL.